TIPA Previously Published Contest 2023

Critical Review ( Division 2) Back

  • Place Name: First Place
    Contestant Name: Del Mar College
    Entry Title: Rumor has it: 'Rumors' was a hit
    Entry Credit: Andrew-Pól Clements
    Judge Comment: The writer knew how to convey his opinion while also respecting the subject matter. I appreciate the unique topic and depth to which he reviewed and critiqued the play.
  • Place Name: Second Place
    Contestant Name: Stephen F. Austin
    Entry Title: REVIEW: The Piano Lesson an experience that pays for itself
    Entry Credit: Jason Kieffer
    Judge Comment: Great evaluation of a unique subject. I appreciate that the author respected the subject matter while lending both critique and compliment.
  • Place Name: Third Place
    Contestant Name: Dallas College - Richland
    Entry Title: A diamond in the Duff
    Entry Credit: Jack Gann
    Judge Comment: I could hear the writer's voice throughout the piece, although the many cliches were nearly distracting. However, they lent themselves to the author's levity.
  • Place Name: Honorable Mention
    Contestant Name: Tarrant County College
    Entry Title: Metroid Prime Remastered
    Entry Credit: Xavier Boatner
    Judge Comment: Good review. The author is clearly knowledgable on this topic. The writing is not as deep/strong, but there are sprinkles of eloquence that elevate the piece as a whole.
  • Competition Comment: None