TIPA Previously Published Contest 2022

Critical Review Division 3 Back

  • Place Name: First Place
    Contestant Name: UT-Tyler
    Entry Title: Taylor Swift’s Album ‘Midnights’ Takes the World by Storm
    Entry Credit: Breanna Bolle, Paulina Mata
    Judge Comment: This is the winner in a weak category – not because the critics are poor writers or lazy thinkers, but simply because they were so brief in their word count, they didn’t have space to back up their nuances. Here, the music clips do some of the heavy lifting, but every word tells.
  • Place Name: Second Place
    Contestant Name: Eastfield College
    Entry Title: Et Cetera Critical Review 2
    Entry Credit: Matt Faught
    Judge Comment: A great concept, and frankly, the distance between first and second was razor-thin. What might have helped: Clips from those movies or just a little more delta to back up the premise.
  • Place Name: Third Place
    Contestant Name: Amarillo College
    Entry Title: Nope, well, maybe
    Entry Credit: Brennan Holmich
    Judge Comment: This entry was also too short to support its thesis, but the lede is just so damn good, it deserves recognition.
  • Competition Comment: None